Featured Post

Review: Southern Pines Golf Club (Part 1)

For our final golf course on this North Carolina getaway, we turn to Southern Pines, which would appear on a surface level to be the third m...

Showing posts with label preserve at eisenhower. Show all posts
Showing posts with label preserve at eisenhower. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 18, 2022

Review: The Preserve at Eisenhower (Part 2)

It's time to take a look at Eisenhower's back nine, go here to see the front.

The tenth hole is fairly long at 425 yards, but it plays something like 30 or 40 feet downhill and the fairway is very wide as it tumbles down, so this is a great opportunity to go for a big drive. Do that, and you'll have a wedge into the green. It's not a large target, best approached from the right side of the fairway, and the green is surrounded by mounding. It's also fairly undulating, with distinct upper and lower sections. It's not a tough hole, but I like it. You can have fun with the drive, and the second shot and green are tricky enough to make the hole not a pushover.

The tenth hole.

Approaching the tenth green.

The tenth green.

The eleventh hole is actually the shortest par 4 at Eisenhower, though it's 390 yards, which isn't exactly driveable. This course doesn't feature a huge amount of variety in the length of its par 4s. There's water running down the entire right side of the hole, but there's plenty of space to bail out left. And the net protecting the hole from the driving range also keeps balls from disappearing. That said, the green is much easier to approach from the right side. It's small, narrow, and pressed hard against the water. Left of the green is an easy bailout, but the green subtly slopes from left to right toward the water, so chipping from the left side is a delicate operation. 

The eleventh hole.

The eleventh green.

The twelfth hole is a 490 yard par 5, but it's not exactly the sort of short par 5 you can reasonably reach in two. For one, using driver is not recommended, since the fairway runs out at about 275 yards, and there's the pond right to consider. Then the second shot plays uphill to a small green at the very top of the hill. It's a small and shallow green as well, with falloffs on every side (most notably right and front left). So if you hit a good 3 wood and a solid long iron, you can reach the green in two, but considering all the hole throws at you, eagle is not a likely result.

The twelfth hole.

Approaching the twelfth green.

The twelfth green.

The thirteenth hole is a reasonably dramatic (as least as dramatic as this course gets) par 3 playing downhill to a large green with water in front and to the right. It's tough when the hole is cut in front like it was for our round, since you want to give the water a wide berth, but playing safe and aiming for the middle or back end of the green leaves you with a gigantic putt. And you can't two putt the 60 or 70 footers every time. 

The thirteenth hole.

The fourteenth hole plays 530 yards to a blind fairway on the other side of a wide valley. The fairway is not wide and surrounded by dense trees, so it's not a hole to swing wildly away at. You need a long, accurate drive to have a hope of reaching the green in two. For most people, this is a three-shot hole, with the second threaded between a series of mounds on both sides of the fairway to set up a wedge third. The green is narrow and sloped significantly from back to front, and there's a deep grass bunker along the left side, with smaller mounding right. Not an easy par 5.

The fourteenth hole.

Approaching the fourteenth green.

The fourteenth green.

The fifteenth hole is the shortest hole at Eisenhower, playing 160 yards over a bit of marsh. There's more marsh and dense forest right and long, and there's big mounding left, but the green is flatter than some of the others. Hit the green and you have a good chance for birdie.

The fifteenth hole.

The sixteenth hole is the longest and toughest hole at Eisenhower, playing nearly 550 yards as it bends through wetland and dense forests. If you want to use driver, you'll need a big fade precisely faded around the corner of the dogleg; if you don't have that shot, you'll want to use a 3 wood. Of course, that makes this a distinctly three-shot hole, but it would be anyway for the vast majority of us who aren't professional golfers. The second shot is squeezed between wetland left and overhanging trees right, and then the third is slightly uphill to a small two-tiered green. I wish the hole was a bit wider, but environmental concerns are a thing, so I'm sure this hole is as wide as is allowed.

The sixteenth hole.

Approaching the sixteenth green.

The sixteenth green.

The seventeenth hole is a mid-length par 3 that is pleasantly free of any hazards. But that doesn't make it easy, since this hole relies heavily on contours and undulations. The green is long, narrow, and is never flat, so putts have plenty of break. There's a series of hollows right and long as well. Much like the thirteenth, three putting is a definite possibility. Still, it's a nice change of pace after the past few holes, which were pretty claustrophobic.

The seventeenth hole.

The seventeenth green.

The eighteenth hole is a 425 yard par 4 that plays from a high tee down to a fairway that steadily slopes uphill. So you won't be getting much roll. Aiming down the right side to reduce the dogleg is risky, as there are overhanging trees to catch out approach shots. You can easily be blocked out from the green, even in the right edge of the fairway. The green is semiblind, tucked behind a ridge, and filled with subtle undulation. It's a fairly understated finishing hole, not easy, but not difficult. 

The eighteenth hole.

The eighteenth green.

I don't doubt that Eisenhower is a more interesting golf course now than it was before the renovation. There's some good stuff here, and in general I like what I saw. Some of the holes on the back nine, the ones in the forest, are a bit too tight for my liking, but I'm guessing clear cutting several hundred trees was out of the budget for a municipal golf course. So I'll give that a pass. Also, if you're judicious about timing and willing to walk, you can play for less than $50, which really isn't too bad for a new public golf course in the heart of the Baltimore-Washington urban conglomeration. It's almost a bargain, compared with most of its neighbors.

On the other hand, while it's a good golf course, it never really elevates itself beyond that. I was expecting a bit more from the guy who renovated so many great Golden Age golf courses to such positive reviews. I was hoping for more fairway undulation and while the greens weren't uninteresting, they weren't exactly inspired either. There was some mounding and hollows to replace bunkers, but a few more wouldn't have gone amiss either. For doing something as radical as removing every single bunker, Eisenhower went for a surprisingly conservative approach. And that's a bit disappointing to me, after going through so much effort, why not make the course as good as it could be? It had good land movement, why not apply some interesting microcontours? This could have been a bold statement, a truly new direction for golf to take, but instead, I feel like Eisenhower is going to be more of a novelty. An interesting experiment, but not much more. 

Wednesday, May 11, 2022

Review: The Preserve at Eisenhower (Part 1)

It isn't too often you see something truly new in golf, and to be fair, a bunkerless golf course isn't a completely unique concept. However, it certainly isn't very common, especially when the course wasn't initially designed that way (and isn't a bare-bones par 3 course). But that's the path that the Preserve at Eisenhower took, which, despite the horribly pretentious name, is actually a municipal golf course just outside Annapolis, Maryland. It was initially designed in the late 60s by Ed Ault, and by 2017 the course was in rough shape. Municipal courses just get beat up, even when they're not quite as old as some others I've played in the past. 

To rectify their problem, the county brought in Andrew Green, an architect who has racked up quite a resume in the past few years, with his renovations of courses like Inverness, Oak Hill, and Congressional. He suggested that Eisenhower get rid of all its bunkers, both to save money and the pace of play. The county agreed, and the renovation went ahead, with the course opening in May 2021. So, the question is: How does a bunkerless golf course work? 

The first hole is exactly 400 yards from the blue tees. (Eisenhower does have a "championship" set of tees at over 7,100 yards, we won't be using those. The blue tees are 6,700 yards, which is much more reasonable.) It doglegs slightly right around a steep slope filled with trees, with the drive best hit down the left side of the fairway, which is generous but not exactly wide. That leaves a short iron or wedge into the green, which falls away sharply both left and long. It's a pretty big green, and if you miss right or short, you'll can putt from the fairway easily enough. It's not the most undulating green in the world, but it's not flat either.

The first hole.

Approaching the first green.

The first green.

The second hole is also about 400 yards and plays from a high tee across a marshy native area to a fairway that quickly heads back up out of the valley. There's dense forest on both sides and not a huge amount of space in between, so driver may not be the wisest play. Of course, using an iron or fairway wood means you'll have a pretty long second. Not much roll available on this fairway. That'll leave a short or mid iron up the hill to a shallow, undulating green. 

The second hole.

Approaching the second green.

The second green.

The third hole is a bit longer than the previous two holes, but it plays downhill. You can hit driver off of the tee and get some pretty impressive distance from bouncing down the hill, but the fairway narrows considerably and you'll be left with an awkward stance. That's especially true if you just miss the fairway right, as there's a series of mounds running along for 50 yards, right where many people would hit their driver. Laying up at the top of the slope means you'll have a longer second, but it'll be from a level lie. The green is fairly shallow and slopes from back to front, with the back corner being especially built up. 

The third hole.

The third green.

The fourth hole is 410 yards and plays gently but steadily uphill. The fairway slopes sharply from left to right down toward a native area, so if you play a fade you'll definitely want to aim down the left side. Of course, a series of mounds left pinches the fairway where a good drive would end up, so that's something else to think about. The green is semiblind but fairly large and very open, so there's room to miss it and still have a reasonable chance of getting up and down. 

The fourth hole.

Approaching the fourth green.

The fifth hole heads back down the hill the fourth climbed up, though it's slightly longer and much tighter. It's a very tough tee shot, squeezed between forest left and native area (with more trees) right, though the fairway is a bit wider than it looks from the tee. Not by much, but enough. Driver is risky, but since the hole is 420 yards, using a fairway wood or long iron will result in a very long second shot. At the very least the green is wide open, but it's also pretty undulating. So all in all, not an easy hole.

The fifth hole.

Approaching the fifth green.

The fifth green.

Finally, after five holes, the sixth hole is something other than a par 4. At 165 yards, it's not a long hole, but it's got native area left and a marshy area right. In addition, the green has several subtle but noticeable sections. It's not easy to putt or chip on, so even though it's decently sized, the sixth is not an easy hole.

The sixth hole.

The seventh hole is the first par 5 at Eisenhower, and the tee shot is not the most interesting thing in the world. The fairway is wide, and there's no real trouble other than the trees. So you can swing freely with driver to try and get within range of the green in two. For those who are laying up, a series of mounds about 75 yards short of the green eat into the left side of the fairway, and you don't want to be in those. The green is wide but not deep, and slopes from left to right.

The seventh hole.

Approaching the seventh green.

The seventh green.

The eighth hole is a downhill par 3 that's on the longer side at nearly 200 yards. It plays over a marshy area, but there's a decent space between that and the green, so it's not a huge problem. Much like the previous hole, the eighth green is wide and shallow, and it's elevated on all sides. There's more native area and trees long, so you definitely want to err on the side of caution on this tee. Short is probably the best place to miss since the green slopes from back to front.

The eighth hole.

The eighth green.

The ninth hole is a 400 yard par 4 that swings right to left as it climbs up a hill toward the clubhouse. You're actually better off sticking to the right side on the drive; it leaves you a longer second but there's not as much risk of being blocked off by trees. That can happen if you go left and don't get far enough. Also, there's a group of mounds that can catch hooked drives. The second shot is to a semiblind green split down the middle into two distinct tiers, with the right side higher than the left. There's certainly more room to miss right, but recovery is easier from the left side of the green, since you can use the slope as a backstop. Not an easy hole to finish off the front nine.

The ninth hole.

Approaching the ninth green.

The ninth green.

That's it for this week, next week we'll take a look at the back nine.