Featured Post

Review: Southern Pines Golf Club (Part 1)

For our final golf course on this North Carolina getaway, we turn to Southern Pines, which would appear on a surface level to be the third m...

Showing posts with label cumberland. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cumberland. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 17, 2025

Review: Rocky Gap Golf Course (Part 2)

It's time to check out the back nine at Rocky Gap, go here to see the front.

The tenth hole is a 560-yard par 5 that initially plays over open, flat ground. Three bunkers surround the otherwise-wide fairway, though the right-side bunker can be carried pretty easily. That's definitely the side to favor. Now, while I'm sure there are people who can get to this green in two, in practical terms no one is doing that. The green here is wide and shallow, and separated completely from the fairway by a stream running across the front. There is just no space available for a fairway wood to successfully hit and hold the green, particularly as you'll be hitting from a downhill lie. This is distinctly a three-shot hole, with the second a matter of keeping the ball in play and leaving yourself a good yardage. Even so, the third is also from a downhill lie and not exactly a walk in the park. I don't imagine a whole lot of birdies are made here.

The tenth hole.

Approaching the tenth green.

The tenth green.

The eleventh hole is 420 yards, and while the tee is elevated, the hole plays otherwise uphill the entire way. The fairway is reasonably wide, but there's dense forest left and a couple of large trees right to keep the right side from being too obvious a bailout. A good drive will leave a short or mid iron uphill to a shallow, two-tiered green tucked behind a large bunker. It's better approached from the right side, but even so, the approach is a tough one.

The eleventh hole.

Approaching the eleventh green.

The eleventh green.

The twelfth hole is 160 yards and plays slightly uphill to a large green with two flanking bunkers. The big thing with this particular green is that the front third or so is in a little amphitheater of sorts, with the back portion being much higher. It's a nice little collection area if the green is in front, but if you end up on the wrong level, two-putting will be tricky.

The twelfth hole.

The twelfth green.

The thirteenth hole is a very long par 5 at nearly 600 yards (they did not have the tees anywhere close to being that far back for my round), though the distance is certainly mitigated by the fact that the fairway tumbles downhill something like 50 feet from tee to green. There's tall grass and a road left, so right is the place to miss, even with a big fairway bunker on that side. This green is out of reach for most golfers, but even on the lay-up, you still need to think about the pond right; you can lay back and take it out of play completely, but then you'll have a hundred-plus yards on the third shot, and that's not a great feeling. The green itself is fairly narrow and curled around the pond, with a bunker short left and beyond.

The thirteenth hole.

Approaching the thirteenth green.

The thirteenth green.

The fourteenth hole is a mid-length par 4 with a small stream cutting across the fairway about 275 yards out from the tee. There's enough brush and tall grass on either side to preclude clearing it, so this tee shot is a pretty straightforward lay-up where you want to avoid the two fairway bunkers right. A 3 wood will leave a short or mid iron to the green, which is medium sized and well protected by two large bunkers. It's not an easy second shot, with the front bunker pretty much necessitating a fully aerial approach.

The fourteenth hole.

Approaching the fourteenth green.

The fourteenth green.

The fifteenth hole is technically the shortest of Rocky Gap's par 5s, being slightly shorter than the fifth. Of course, that hole played more than a hundred feet downhill, while this one plays slowly but surely uphill. It's a narrow fairway here as well, squeezed on both sides by trees and tall grass. The second is going to be a lay-up for most people anyway, but a large bunker cuts the fairway off about 75 yards from the green, and with precious little space between wood lines beyond it, the third shot will be a full wedge. There's just no good reason to play this hole any other way. The green is narrow, with a bunker left to protect slightly wayward shots from disappearing. 

The fifteenth hole.

Approaching the fifteenth green.

The fifteenth green.

The sixteenth hole is 190 yards and plays downhill to a shallow green sloped sharply from back to front protected by bunkers in front and to the left. It's not the greatest hole in the world, mostly because it's a bit too long for how little green there is to work with, particularly with that bunker in front.

The sixteenth hole.

The seventeenth hole is also a par 3, playing 180 yards to a long, narrow green poking out into the forest. There are two bunkers, one short and one left, and the green is subtly undulating and tricky to putt. This is by far the better of the back-to-back par 3s, and it looks very good carved out of the hillside. 

The seventeenth hole.

The seventeenth green.

The eighteenth hole is a long-ish par 4 at 430 yards, and while in isolation I think this is a solid hole, it doesn't really fit in with everything else we've seen. The fairway, while framed by bunkers, is wide open and virtually devoid of trees, and that feels like a strange choice on an otherwise very forested golf course. The green is well-bunkered and quite similar to the twelfth, with the front portion being in its own separate tier below the back half. It's not a terrible green design, though I'm not sure we needed to repeat it.

The eighteenth hole.

Approaching the eighteenth green.

The eighteenth green.

All things considered, it would be pretty baffling if Rocky Gap weren't at least somewhat interesting, considering the abrupt, severe landscape. And it certainly has some memorable holes, particularly the fifth and sixth. But the property, of course, also holds Rocky Gap back. The land is too broken and mountainous for really good golf. Simply getting to 18 holes had to have been a challenge, and you can really tell the architect was struggling at the end with the back-to-back par 3s.

The course was in solid shape, and while it's not walkable (I'm sure you could, theoretically, but I didn't), the price was reasonable. $60 for 18 holes with a cart is really not too bad, and this is a better-than-average golf course. That price does come with a caveat, however: You have to play after 2 PM. The normal, non-twilight rate is over a hundred bucks, and that is way, way too much. So long as I can get that twilight rate, I would play here again. It's a reasonably fun and scenic golf course.


Wednesday, December 10, 2025

Review: Rocky Gap Golf Course (Part 1)

In Maryland, once you go west of Hagerstown, it's tough to find space for golf. The terrain is rugged and there is quite literally very little land between the Potomac to the south and the Mason-Dixon Line to the north. Maryland quite infamously narrows down to less than 2 miles wide when you reach Hancock. It's small wonder than that the first golf course you find past Hagerstown is very nearly in Cumberland, 50 miles to the west. It's also little wonder that Rocky Gap Casino, Resort, and Golf Course is pretty much on I-68, the main road through western Maryland, so much so that the exit for the resort (and state park) pretty much feels like its for Rocky Gap and nothing else.

There is another reason to be curious about Rocky Gap beyond geographic convenience — it was designed by Jack Nicklaus. Now, I should probably qualify that statement and say that I highly doubt Mr. Nicklaus, he of 18 majors fame, made more than a cursory publicity visit to Rocky Gap (if he even did that). It was almost certainly someone at his architecture firm who did the real work. Still, it says Jack Nicklaus designed the course on the website, and I've never played a Nicklaus golf course. So, what could his team to with the rugged landscape of western Maryland? Let's find out.

The first hole does a decent job at setting the tone for the round in terms of what you're going to see. The landforms are severe and the fairway pretty clearly had to be carved out of a hillside. This par 4 is about 380 yards, and the fairway is pinched between three bunkers, two left and one right. A fade is the better choice on the tee. A good drive will leave just a wedge. The green is medium sized with a bunker left, and while I wouldn't call it a particularly wild or interesting green, it's definitely not flat. All in all, a reasonable opening hole.

The first hole.

Approaching the first green.

The first green.

The second hole is also about 380 yards, though it plays quite differently. The tee shot climbs dramatically to a fairway that turns left around a deep bunker. You ideally want to reach the top of the hill to get a view of the green, but between the bunker left and the scrub-covered hillside right, there's not a massive amount of space for a driver. It's not impossible, but nor is it the most inviting prospect. If you do use driver successfully, your reward will be a little wedge slightly downhill to a green cut into the hillside with a bunker left keeping slightly wayward approaches from bounding down into oblivion.

The second hole.

The second green.

The third hole is a long 450-yard par 4 playing through a chute of trees to a wide, sloped fairway with native areas and woods on both sides. The fairway does end at some point, but you'd have to hit it at 300 yards for that to be a concern. The second shot is a mid iron over that central valley to a green on the far side. It's got a single, deep bunker front right, and the green is medium sized and angled from left to right. You definitely want to approach the green from the left side of the fairway; even so, this is a tough second shot and a tough hole overall.

The third hole.

Approaching the third green.

The third green.

The fourth hole is a shortish par 3 at 160 yards, which is made even shorter as the hole plays significantly downhill. The green is sloped from left to right, following the slope of the hillside its carved from. There's a shallow bunker left and a very deep one front right. Neither are fun to be in. Still, the hole isn't long and the green, while not massive, definitely isn't small. 

The fourth hole.

The fourth green.

The fifth hole is a dramatic 540-yard par 5 tumbling a hundred feet downhill to a massively wide fairway split into upper and lower levels by a pair of central bunkers. While the upper side gives you a better angle, the fairway ends about 275 yards out, meaning that longer hitters will run out of driver space. The right, lower side has more space, but it also puts you behind trees and prevents you from going directly at the green in two. The trees pinch in from the right around 75 yards from the green, so you either need to lay up well short of that or get past that on the lay-up. A single bunker protects the right side of the green, which is otherwise pretty straightforward. Even so, this is a fun and memorable hole, and definitely the sort of thing you expect to see in such a mountainous setting.

The fifth hole.

Approaching the fifth green.

The fifth green.

Speaking of holes that feel carved out of the wilderness, the sixth hole is quite intimidating when you step onto the tee. Actual golf terrain is scarcely visible. All you get is a few slivers of the green in between dense underbrush. This is a 220-yard par 3 with a green far below in a valley, but while the tee shot looks incredibly difficult, there's actually plenty of open space down there to work with. It's not easy, and the green has a couple of bunkers around it, but it's nowhere near as tough to lose a golf ball here as you might think.

Not much to see from the back tee on the sixth hole..

It's a little better from the next tee up, but not by much.

The sixth green.

The seventh hole is a medium-length par 4 playing to a narrow fairway with forest on both sides, as well as a single bunker right. That bunker can be cleared with a driver, but with little wiggle room it's a tough choice to make. A good long iron or fairway wood will leave a short iron for the approach. The green here is on the far side of a tiny stream (barely more than a trickle when I was there, though admittedly western Maryland was experiencing a pretty severe drought), and while it's quite narrow, it's also pretty flat. Find the green and you'll have a decent chance at birdie.

The seventh hole.

Approaching the seventh green.

The seventh green.

The eighth hole is not a long par 5, being just over 500 yards, but it also plays dramatically (if steadily) uphill. It would take two big shots to get to the green in two. The hole isn't overflowing with hazards, with just one small fairway bunker right, but since the hole is quite narrow, it doesn't need much else as it squeezes through the trees. The green here is the most interesting part of the hole; it's separated into three distinct sections, an upper tier at the back, with a central ridge dividing the front two-thirds of the green into roughly equal halves. Find the wrong section of green, and two putting will be a challenge.

The eighth hole.

Approaching the eighth green.

The eighth green.

The ninth hole is another mid-length par 4, and like the second this one plays up to an elevated fairway. With the hole bending slightly left and a cluster of trees positioned in the corner, you really need a draw on hand if you want to use driver here. For most, a fairway wood is the play, hopefully reaching the top of the hill and leaving a short iron or wedge second shot. The green is fairly narrow and squeezed between two large bunkers.

The ninth hole.

The ninth green.

That's it for this week, next week we'll check out the back nine.

Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Review: Fore Sisters Golf Club (Part 2)

We're back with the back nine at Fore Sisters, go here if you haven't seen the front.

The tenth hole is a short but not quite drivable par 4 at 340 yards. The fairway is sloped from left to right, and there's a noticeable dip in the fairway about 200-225 yards from the tee. The second shot is back up to a small green guarded by two bunkers. Going long leaves you a tough downhill chip to a green that slopes away.

The tenth hole.

The tenth green.
The eleventh hole is a downhill par 3 over a small pond to a severely tilted green more closely guarded by two bunkers. There's quite a bit of break on putts here, and it can be easy to race putts by if you're going downhill. It's a decent hole, I just wish it wasn't the same length as all the other par 3s at Fore Sisters.

The eleventh hole.
The twelfth hole is a fairly short par 4, less than 350 yards, though it plays uphill. The fairway rises and falls as it heads up, and there's a noticeable tilt from left to right. The green is guarded by a single bunker front right. This hole actually returns back to the clubhouse, I'm guessing that not a lot of people stop at 9, and instead play up to this hole if they don't want to go all 18.

The twelfth hole.

The twelfth green.
The thirteenth hole is the longest par 4 at Fore Sisters, though it's not even 400 yards. This isn't a long golf course. Interestingly, the distance between green and tee is probably not much more than 200 yards. If it weren't for the dense forest, the green would be easily drivable. That's because the hole is shaped like a big U. You hit your drive about 225 down the fairway, make a more than 90 degree turn, then go over a small native area to the green with a short to mid iron. The green is bunkerless, but it is quite small and has a noticeable back to front tilt. This is the sort of goofy hole I like seeing on courses like this. It helps give Fore Sisters a certain quirky charm.

The thirteenth hole. The green is pretty much straight to the right.

Approaching the thirteenth green.

Looking back down the thirteenth hole.
The fourteenth hole is a fairly unique proposition in the world of golf. You don't see par 6s every day; in fact, it's the first I've ever come across. 740 yards, uphill the entire way. Okay, the current management has placed the tees at a more reasonable 580 yards, but the far back teeing area, the one at 700+ yards, was in better shape than pretty much any other tee on the course, so my brother and I couldn't resist giving the full hole a try. Shockingly, 740 yards is lot. The hole is kind of a slog, to be honest. It's dead straight, there are no hazards save for the trees lining the fairway, and it's pretty much straight. The green, once you get to it, is guarded by two bunkers. Is this a good hole? Of course not. But it was fun giving it a try once.

You're in for a long journey on 14.

The uphill tee shot on 14.

Trust me, the green's out there somewhere.

Getting closer...

The fourteenth green at long last.

Looking back at the long trek up 14.
The fifteenth hole is yet another par 3 of roughly 170 yards, but this is easily the best of the bunch. The green is angled away at a 45 degree angle, and there's a big drop-off short and right. Long and left isn't much better. It's not a particularly easy hole, and since apparently this is the only length that Fore Sisters can manage from its par 3s, it's nice to get a little bit of variety.

The fifteenth hole.

The fifteenth green.
The sixteenth hole is a par 5 of roughly 500 yards, playing back down the mountain. The uphill climb is finally over. The most obvious issue on the tee is the tree sitting in the middle of the corridor between the forest lines. There is not a lot of room to work with. If you manage to negotiate the trees, the hole is pretty easy. It's easily reachable in two, and the green is only guarded by one bunker. It's a great birdie opportunity.

The sixteenth hole, complete with inconvenient tree.

Approaching the sixteenth hole.

The sixteenth green.
The seventeenth hole is a mid-length par 4 at 360 yards. It's a slight dogleg left, and the fairway is tilted from right to left. The green is small, but shots can be run up from the right side. Definitely not the most challenging penultimate hole in the world.

The seventeenth hole.

The seventeenth green.
The eighteenth hole is a thoroughly underwhelming finish. It's technically the longest par 3 at Fore Sisters, but it's still under 200 yards, and that distance is further mitigated since the hole plays downhill. There are no bunkers, and the green is reasonably sized, though it does slope slightly away from the tee. That's the most interesting part of this hole. Considering some of the goofiness we've seen, it was disappointing to end on such a bland note.

The eighteenth hole.
As far as golf courses go, Fore Sisters is a less than impressive example. There are some fun and quirky holes, but the course is so narrow and tree lined it's difficult to appreciate them without feeling claustrophobic. You have to be accurate here, or you will not have a fun day. It's not a particularly thorough examination either, no par 4 tops 400 yards, and the par 3s are all pretty much exactly the same length. A big chunk of the course's 6,200 yards comes at that par 6.

However, despite the shortcomings, I would consider Fore Sisters worth at least one round, for no other reason than its location. You're in the mountains of western Maryland, and it is deep in the wild. Honestly, playing Fore Sisters feels more like a hike than a round of golf, and if you approach it like that, the course starts to make a lot more sense. The course traverses rugged terrain, and you'll have plenty of scenery to look at. It only costs $20 to walk 18, a price I would consider worthwhile. If I played the course regularly I'd probably spend the extra $12 to get a cart, but I doubt I'll be coming back, and I'm glad I got the experience of walking around Fore Sisters. It felt like a real adventure, and that's not a feeling you get all that often playing golf.